Travesty of Justice
Travesty of Justice
Judge sentences Steven Donziger to six months in federal prison
One of the most compelling court cases in recent years is the prosecution of human rights and environmental lawyer Steven Donziger by Chevron Oil.
Yes, you read that correctly.
A multi-national fossil fuel giant was able to use a US courtroom to prosecute - and sentence to prison! - a Harvard educated environmental lawyer who led a team that successfully challenged their criminal drilling practices in the Ecuadorian Amazon. The case has sent shivers through the environmental movement, signally as it does the viciousness with which oil conglomerates will come after those who dare to threaten their hegemony.
In the 1960’s Texaco Oil began illegal drilling in Ecuador, intentionally saving $3 a pit by refusing to line them. This caused devastating carcinogenic effects on water, food and air – on which thousands of farmers depended for their survival. Chevron bought Texaco in the year 2000, yet when the Supreme Court of Ecuador handed down a judgement of $9.5B that Chevron owed in compensation to the Ecuadorian farmers, the company refused to pay the judgement - and decided to come after Steven Donziger instead!
And come after him they did. Donziger’s alleged crime is a grade B misdemeanor, his having refused a court order to turn over this electronic equipment to Chevron. When a NY Court decided to pass on prosecuting him for that, Judge Lewis Kaplan used a legal loophole to turn over prosecution of the case to Chevron. Given that Donziger’s computer was filled with confidential information regarding names and whereabouts of Ecuadorian environmental activists, in his case the violation of attorney-client privilege would have had particularly egregious consequences.
Two years of home confinement – unheard of for a grade B misdemeanor – preceded Donziger’s trial and sentencing. During that time, the public outcry on his behalf has grown. The UN High Commissioner on Human Rights has called on the United States to release Donziger, claiming that his confinement is an arbitrary violation of his human rights. Congressmen, Senators and scores of Nobel Laureates have demanded his release. Attorney General Merrick Garland has been asked by Congresspeople as well as by members of the public to return the case to the US justice system. More and more Americans are aware of the dangers of allowing a multi-national corporation to use a US courtroom to prosecute those who resist its policies.
Today, the Chevron-supported judge, aided by the Chevron-supported prosecution, sentenced Donziger to the maximum time of six months in federal prison. A powerful movement urging Donziger’s freedom has grown up around this case, as many have come to see it as a sign of something much more dangerous than just the unjust prosecution of one man. It has become a symbol of corporate tyranny and the reaction people have to it. It is certainly a chilling message to all environmentally concerned citizens: “Don’t try to come after us, or we will come after you.”
Below is a statement issued after the judge’s sentencing by the organization Amazon Watch:
As expected judge Loretta Preska sentenced Steven Donziger to the maximum sentence of six months in federal prison for the petty misdemeanor contempt of court charges filed by pro-Chevron former tobacco-industry lawyer now judge Lewis Kaplan.
The charges were prosecuted by corporate law firm Seward & Kissel (a Chevron law firm) appointed by Kaplan himself. Preska herself was hand picked by Kaplan to try the case. Preska not only dismissed the recent decision by the UNs Working Group on Arbitrary Detention that Donziger should be not only freed but compensated as his detention is a human rights violation, but in flagrantly poor taste employed the brutal metaphor that Donziger should be hit between the eyes with a proverbial two by four”.
The saga of Chevron’s perversion of the law and denial of justice for the people of Ecuador reached a new chapter as Donziger was even denied bail pending appeal of the decision. His legal team has one week to challenge that denial and if he loses he will have to report to federal prison for six months to appeal while incarcerated. While this is another slap in the face to environment justice, Chevron, their lawyers at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, Kaplan, Preska and Rita Glavin of Seward and Kissel have only succeeded in generating more support for Donziger and the movement for justice in Ecuador.
Considerable pressure will continue to mount on the Biden Administration to intervene and put an end to the farce that has placed the rights and profits of the second largest oil company in the US - Chevron, over those of affected communities and their advocates.
Stay tuned to FreeDonziger.com for details about what happens now, Donziger’s appeal, and other aspects of this travesty of justice. I don’t feel like this thing is over; in a way it has only just begun. I will appear on The Rising on The Hill TV on Monday to discuss the case further.
No matter what, don’t get mad. Just get busy…
EDIT: Here’s an update from Krystal Ball’s Breaking Points
Listened to most of Judge Preska’s summation & was thoroughly appalled at her tone & demeanor. To be clear, I’m no legal scholar, but when she claimed he needed to be “hit between the eyes with a proverbial two by four” because he (paraphrasing here) is a threat to “the foundations” of the American justice system (huh?)…I felt a little nauseous.🤢
(Pretty rich stuff from a Federalist Society judge presiding over a trial reaking of corruption & conflicts of interest…)
Had to force myself to listen & bear witness…but it was definitely demoralizing to hear.
Deep gratitude, Marianne, for all you do and are and for this update outlined so clearly and fully. I agree that this is more the beginning of what comes from this rather than the end. Personally, I am feeling kind of numb today and so your words have been particularly helpful. And so, we keep on. Thank you for keeping us informed.